| Chess Playing Software (non-Windows) | ||||||||||
| Behind Before You Buy Chess Playing Software (non-Windows) | ||||||||||
(Augsut 2003)
As certain as spring leads to summer, whenever a hardware engineer develops a new computer processor, a software engineer follows with a new program to play chess.
We imagine that some day soon you will be able to play chess with your fridge or with your car.
Science fiction aside, the About Chess article on 'Chess Playing Software for Windows' (see the link box in the upper right corner) promised 'a companion article on commercial chess playing software for the non-Windows world'.
To keep this promise we released a new Buyer's Guide article, Before You Buy Chess Playing Software (non-Windows) (see the link box again).
We identified five distinct platforms or computing environments where chess playing products have been developed : Macs, Linux/Unix, game consoles, PDAs, and cell phones.
While we were investigating the different products for these platforms, we realized that enough software exists for both the Palm and the PocketPC to justify separate mention.
We also realized that the operating systems which drive PDAs and cell phones are in many cases the same underlying product.
To resolve this we decided to leave space for a brief discussion of operating systems for handheld devices.
This opened the door for Windows CE in an article about non-Windows software, but WinCE is too important to ignore.
Since we were covering handheld devices, we decided that a brief mention of handheld computers was appropriate and fair.
Anyone looking for a mobile chess partner should consider handheld chess computers as an option.
This brings us to a discussion on how to classify chess playing software. There are several ways to do this. We could have started from the viewpoint of someone who wants to buy the best product for a specific task across similar platforms. This would be the case if you're looking for a product to use while traveling or on vacation. We could also have started from the viewpoint of someone who has a specific brand in mind, but wants to buy it for the most effective platform. In fact, there are not many products available on multiple platforms. ChessGenius is the outstanding exception, with versions for a wide range of platforms. Chess Tiger and Fritz are sold in both desktop and heldheld categories, although we doubt that the versions compete against the same product in the other category. We started instead from the viewpoint of someone who wants a product for a specific platform. This assumes that anyone looking for a chess program already uses a computer where chess will be another widget to add to the office, leisure, and other software products used daily.
Given a specific platform, there are several factors which influence the buying decision. The two most important are undoubtedly ease-of-use and playing strength. Aside from a few comparisons of board displays, we found neither ease-of-use comparisons nor objective measurement criteria. Neither did we find any attempt to determine ratings or to compare playing strength. It appears that this area is wide open for pioneers who have the time and the patience to compare these many products with each other. One final note : although this article targets commercial programs, we found nothing for Linux and Unix. The chess software for this important computing family is the domain of the hobbyist. This deserves a separate article, because we know that non-commercial chess software -- freeware and shareware -- is a big subject and can't be covered briefly. |
||||||||||

